Hello Guest. Please Login or Register.
Nov 22nd, 2009 at 01:41 pm
Send This Topic To A Friend
Click here to disable ads!

http://www.thewritersguild101.co.uk
5.08 - (Read 74 Times)
 
maxandkiz
Guild Officer


Member is offline



Send email to maxandkiz@yahoo.com Send PM


Posts: 575
Post Icon Posted: Nov 5th, 2009 at 05:29 pm

Here's the place to come and talk about the latest episode.

Looks like we're in for a few laughs with this one.
IP Logged


By maxandkiz
Bayre
Guild Editor


Member is offline

icon by thru terry's eyes

Rock Salt & Silver Moon Send PM


Posts: 565
Post Icon Posted: Nov 5th, 2009 at 09:00 pm

Can I just say, Sam as Kitt----yes!
IP Logged


banner by Sojourner84



banner by sojourner84
maxandkiz
Guild Officer


Member is offline



Send email to maxandkiz@yahoo.com Send PM


Posts: 575
Post Icon Posted: Nov 5th, 2009 at 10:00 pm

Dean fangirling over Dr. Sexy M.D. and Sam in a commercial about Herpes! LOL!

I loved seeing the trickster actor back. He's a hoot!

Oh, and the comment Sam made when Dean was digging in the trunk! Snicker!
IP Logged


By maxandkiz
Spoilerwolf
~ Alpha Wolf ~


Member is offline

~ Guarding the Gates of Hell ~ Hey, the job came with a free t-shirt!!

Send PM


Posts: 290
Post Icon Posted: Nov 6th, 2009 at 01:20 am

Other than the funnies that you guys mentioned, I generally seriously disliked this eppy. Since I did all my ranting in a different forum, I'll leave this post as such Smiley
IP Logged

*Is still sitting in the glass half-full bandwaggon*


Credit for banner goes to JessM
Bayre
Guild Editor


Member is offline

icon by thru terry's eyes

Rock Salt & Silver Moon Send PM


Posts: 565
Post Icon Posted: Nov 6th, 2009 at 08:21 am

What didn't you like?
IP Logged


banner by Sojourner84



banner by sojourner84
jenilee
Ovate


Member is online

Thanks to Beth for the lovely avatar

Send PM

Posts: 473
Post Icon Posted: Nov 6th, 2009 at 10:20 am

I didn't like it either. It was boring and not that funny. Although there were a couple of funny spots. Maybe I'd like it better the second time around. Kitt car Sam had some funny spots and Dean and Dr. sexy(Hello guy from Andromeda whose name I can't remember) had funny spots but the rest was meh.

I disliked it for totally different reason than half the fandom because even though i didn't like the idea behind the trickster being Gabriel(I was starting to expect him to be Uriel in disguise actually) I still think the story will unwrinkle itself as it goes and these sorts of episode will make sense later or maybe it never will make sense. LOL

This trickster being Gabriel thing does kind of screw up this big theory I had going about the trickster playing some ultimate joke on the boys since the end of mystery spot.
A giant lesson to the both of them as to what each of them will do if they continued on the path they were on. And then at the end of it rewind to after mystery spot to find that everything since then was an au world of the tricksters making.
Now that would have cleared up a whole lot of stuff I think and leave it open for Sam to save Dean and have a season six if they get renewed.
IP Logged

Spoilerwolf
~ Alpha Wolf ~


Member is offline

~ Guarding the Gates of Hell ~ Hey, the job came with a free t-shirt!!

Send PM


Posts: 290
Post Icon Posted: Nov 6th, 2009 at 07:16 pm

Nov 6th, 2009 at 08:21 am, Bayre wrote:
What didn't you like?


- No impact from MS for Sam. All about Dean.
- Cas - no reason whatsoever to have him there, and he generally irritates me
- Slap stick comedy is not my taste, so the first chunk of the beginning had me rolling my eyes.
- The Japanese game show Q's. Gee, just what ARE the writers trying to imply here?
- Trickster aka Gabriel. While I still liked him, hated that they made him another whiny angel with Daddy and bro issues.
- The idea that "it was always going to be you two" makes (to me) the mytharc for S1-2 moot and irrevelant. (especially Sam's whole role in this, as well as the PK storyline)
- Kripke is setting this up to be Dean vs Sam... AGAIN
- Dean gets to emote another speech, as per usual.

Just the major things that ticked me off.

things I liked:
- Dean fangirling over Dr.Sexy
- Dean being a geeky fanboy over Dr.Sexy (knowing about him wearing cowboy boots)
- KITT!Sam - that was made of win! lol.
- Sam operating on Dean. "STAT!" lol.

That's about it.
IP Logged

*Is still sitting in the glass half-full bandwaggon*


Credit for banner goes to JessM
AnickaMarie
Scribe


Member is offline


YIM
AnickaMarie's FF.net Send PM


Posts: 210
Post Icon Posted: Nov 6th, 2009 at 08:11 pm

So I did enjoy much of this episode. Although, I'm getting tired of Sam repeatedly getting STDs...much more appropriate for Dean really if they must go there. He's the one with a girl in every hotel room. Did enjoy the commercial more than the 'Clap' last ep though. I laughed through most of the TV show part of the ep and enjoyed the return of the Trickster. He's a great supernatural villain and Richard Speight Jr. does a wonderful job. Not so fond of the reveal that he's been Gabriel all along. I'll see how that ends up though. So in conclusion until the final reveal I was really enjoying the ep but many very thoughtful points have been brought up about how that completely contradicts the first 2 seasons and has loads of issues and I can see where they are coming from. I tend to not dwell overly much on all of this though and usually just enjoy reading everyone's varying takes so I'll def. keep watching.
IP Logged

[ Guest ]calcium77
Post Icon Posted: Nov 8th, 2009 at 10:57 pm

I generally don't like the episodes when they try to be too funny. I like it when they are serious, but funny things happen or are said along the way. Do they writers write these for themselves?

I did laugh at a few things though. And it was not the worst episode I have ever seen.
IP Logged

jenilee
Ovate


Member is online

Thanks to Beth for the lovely avatar

Send PM

Posts: 473
Post Icon Posted: Nov 9th, 2009 at 12:01 am

Yeah when they try to be funny it seems to fall flat for me. I guess I prefer subtle dry humour and stuff with movie refs thinks that you have to think about. I guess it depends too where they are placing it like black rock had some pretty funny stuff in it and yellow fever but this just was silly to begin with so the humour just felt even sillier.
It took me forever to figure out what show they were spoofing at the beginning too and I still can't think of the name but I remember watching it. It had a name like 'just friends' or something like that which considering all the stuff about j2 I can see why they chose that one. It was about these two roommates and the one guy was an immigrant I think his name was balki or something like that. Did you guys used to watch it? the opening credits scene was totally spoofed from it the playing football and running around the park til they fell down together.LOL I'll have to see if I can find it on imdb.
IP Logged

jenilee
Ovate


Member is online

Thanks to Beth for the lovely avatar

Send PM

Posts: 473
Post Icon Posted: Nov 9th, 2009 at 12:08 am

I found it! Only by looking up Balkie. LOL Ok don't ask how I can remember the name of a guy from a show I watched in the early nineties but not robert carlisles character from stargate Universe that I watched last night...go figure.

I was way off on thetv shows name it was called perfect strangers which too could be kind of fitting from the sam and dean point of view. they were cousins in the show though.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0090501/plotsummary
IP Logged

 
 

A great way to get more members is to spread the word about your forum:



Asian Models
Click here to disable ads!

This forum powered for FREE by Hyperboards v2.13
Get your own free forum today!